# Comparing HVAC Bids: A Low Bid That Held, and a 55% Spread

> Four HVAC bids in one real package. The low bid stayed lowest after leveling, but every bid left scope out or unclear. What to check before you award.

- URL: https://consight.ai/articles/comparing-hvac-bids-case-study
- Published: 2026-11-10
- Topic: [Bid Leveling](https://consight.ai/articles/topics/bid-leveling)
- Author: Stewart Toubia

To compare HVAC bids, put every bid on one scope sheet, mark what each bid excludes or leaves unclear, and price the gaps before you compare totals. In one four-bid HVAC package, the low bid stayed lowest after leveling, and the spread from low to high held at 55%.

## Key takeaways

- Bidder A had the low base bid. Bidder D was highest, at 155% of it.
- All four bidders left out or left unclear the same eight kinds of work.
- Bidder D left 7 lines unclear, more than the other three bidders combined.
- The plugs added 0% to every bid, so leveled prices matched base bids and the ranks held.

## What did the four HVAC bids look like on bid day?

This case is one HVAC (Division 23) package on a commercial project under 50,000 sq ft in the South Census region. The scope sheet had 18 lines. Consight read 5 files and 12 pages. The case holds no names, amounts, or dates, so every price below is a percentage of the low base bid.

Bidder A had the low base bid. Bidder B came next, 26% above it. Bidders C and D sat 43% and 55% above.

| Bidder   | Base bid, % of the low base bid | Rank on base bid |
| -------- | ------------------------------- | ---------------- |
| Bidder A | 100%                            | 1                |
| Bidder B | 126%                            | 2                |
| Bidder C | 143%                            | 3                |
| Bidder D | 155%                            | 4                |

The gap between the low and second-low bid was 26%. Across Consight's published benchmark, the median gap on HVAC packages is 23% (33 packages, 32 projects, 8 organizations, base bids before leveling). One organization holds 45% of that sample, and the benchmark does not publish the median without it. This package sat a little above that median.

## Which scope did each HVAC bid leave out or leave unclear?

Every bidder left something out or unclear. Bidder A had 0 excluded lines and 3 unclear lines. The table counts lines for each bidder.

| Bidder   | Lines excluded | Lines unclear |
| -------- | -------------- | ------------- |
| Bidder A | 0              | 3             |
| Bidder B | 0              | 1             |
| Bidder C | 4              | 1             |
| Bidder D | 1              | 7             |

Bidder C excluded the most lines. Bidder D left the most unclear. Both of them also priced well above the low.

Across Consight's published benchmark, 56% of leveled HVAC bids exclude at least one scope line (246 bids, 76 packages, 72 projects, 25 organizations). Without the largest organization, which holds 37% of the sample, the share is 50%. In this case, two of the four bidders excluded a line.

### Which kinds of work did all four bidders name?

The case records each bidder's kinds of work that it left out or left unclear. Bidders A, B, C, and D all named these eight:

- Demolition
- Testing or inspection
- Patching or painting
- Engineering or design
- Temporary power, water, or facilities
- Concrete or equipment pads
- Cutting, coring, or sleeves
- Fire stopping or fire rating

Those eight belong on your own scope sheet or in a plug for every bid.

### Which kinds of work split the field?

The other kinds of work fell on some bidders and not on others.

| Kind of work                           | Bidders that left it out or unclear |
| -------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- |
| Permits or fees                        | A, C                                |
| Overtime or after-hours work           | A, B, C                             |
| Sales or use tax                       | A, B                                |
| Utility company charges or connections | A, C                                |
| Cleanup, dumpsters, or disposal        | C, D                                |

Bidder A, the low base bid, named permits, tax, and utility charges. Bidder B named tax and overtime but not permits.

## What did the plugs add to the HVAC bids?

A plug is the estimator's price for scope a bidder missed, excluded, or underpriced. The case records every bidder's plugs as 0% of the low base bid.

In Consight, the [leveled price](https://consight.ai/reference/pricing-and-leveling#base-bid-vs-leveled-price-explained) is the base bid plus plugs, corrected quantities, and scope the estimator added. The case records the plugs but not the other adjustments. It holds 5 reviewed calls and 5 estimator corrections, and it does not say what they changed.

## Did the low HVAC bid stay lowest after leveling?

Yes. Every leveled price matched its base bid, and the ranks did not move.

| Bidder   | Rank on base bid | Leveled price, % of the low leveled price | Rank after leveling |
| -------- | ---------------- | ----------------------------------------- | ------------------- |
| Bidder A | 1                | 100%                                      | 1                   |
| Bidder B | 2                | 126%                                      | 2                   |
| Bidder C | 3                | 143%                                      | 3                   |
| Bidder D | 4                | 155%                                      | 4                   |

The spread from low to high was 55% before leveling and 55% after. After leveling, Bidder B was 26% above Bidder A, Bidder C 43%, and Bidder D 55%.

A held ranking does not mean a clean bid. Bidder A left 3 lines unclear and named 12 kinds of work. Leveling confirmed the order here, and it still does not decide the award. For a case where leveling reversed the order, read our [electrical case](https://consight.ai/articles/comparing-electrical-bids-case-study). For the step after leveling, see [award when the low bid is not lowest](https://consight.ai/articles/award-when-the-low-bid-is-not-lowest).

## What should you check in HVAC bids before you award?

Run these checks bid by bid. For the method across mechanical trades, see [how to level mechanical and electrical bids](https://consight.ai/articles/how-to-level-mechanical-and-electrical-bids).

1. **The eight shared items.** All four bidders named the eight kinds of work listed above: demolition, testing, patching, engineering, temporary facilities, pads, cutting, and fire stopping. Assign each to a bidder or to another trade in writing.
2. **Unclear lines.** Bidder D left 7 of 18 lines unclear. Send it the unclear lines and ask for a clear yes or no on each.
3. **Refrigerant work.** The EPA's [Section 608 certification page](https://www.epa.gov/section608/section-608-technician-certification) says "Technicians are required to pass an EPA-approved test to earn Section 608 Technician Certification." Ask each bidder whether its technicians hold that certification, and who handles refrigerant recovery.
4. **Ventilation and exhaust.** OSHA's rule [1926.57](https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/29/1926.57) covers ventilation that controls dust, fumes, and gases where employees work. It says exhaust fans, ducts, and hoods "shall be so designed, constructed, maintained and operated as to ensure the required protection." Ask whether any bid carries temporary ventilation.
5. **Permits, tax, and overtime.** Bidders A and C left out or left unclear permits. Bidders A and B did the same for sales or use tax. Bidders A, B, and C did so for overtime.
6. **Utility connections.** Bidders A and C named utility company charges or connections. Decide who pays the utility and who schedules the connection.
7. **Reviewed calls.** Check each bidder's Included, Not Included, and Needs Review marks yourself before you trust a total.

For finding the gaps, see [how to find scope gaps in subcontractor bids](https://consight.ai/articles/how-to-find-scope-gaps-in-subcontractor-bids).

## How does Consight show this?

Consight reads each proposal and answers your Inclusions, Exclusions, Alternates, and Clarifications rows from each bid, as the [help page](https://consight.ai/help/inclusions-exclusions-alternates-and-qualifications) describes. [Level Bids](https://consight.ai/reference/autocomplete#run-level-bids) also marks each scope line Included, Not Included, or Needs Review for each bidder. You [add a plug](https://consight.ai/reference/pricing-and-leveling#add-a-plug-for-missing-or-unclear-scope) for each gap at your own price.

## How we measured

Every case figure comes from one recorded case, `23-hvac-16d2e194`, an HVAC package leveled in Consight. The case holds no names, amounts, or dates. It rounds every percentage to a whole number. Base bids and plugs are percentages of the low base bid. Leveled prices are percentages of the low leveled price.

The case records each bidder's kinds of work as items left out or left unclear, so this page does not split them. The 56% share comes from Consight's published bid benchmark of 2026-11-09. It counts all leveled HVAC bids, and the AI detected the exclusions. The 23% median gap is a recorded value over base bids as submitted. The EPA and OSHA quotes come from the text at the linked pages.
