# Comparing Plumbing Bids: Two Bids Priced 63% Above the Low

> Four plumbing bids in one real package: the low bid stayed lowest and the spread held at 63%. What each bid left out, and what to check before you award.

- URL: https://consight.ai/articles/comparing-plumbing-bids-case-study
- Published: 2026-11-09
- Topic: [Bid Leveling](https://consight.ai/articles/topics/bid-leveling)
- Author: Stewart Toubia

To compare plumbing bids, a general contractor puts every subcontractor's proposal on one scope sheet, marks what each bid includes and excludes, and prices the gaps before comparing totals. In one four-bid plumbing package, the low bid stayed lowest after leveling, and the spread between the low and high bids was 63% before and after.

## What did the four plumbing bids look like when they came in?

This case is one Plumbing (Division 22) package in the South region, on a project of 50,000 to 200,000 sq ft. The case does not record the project type. The scope sheet had 9 lines. Consight read 12 files and 33 pages.

The case holds no names, amounts, or dates, so every price below is a percentage of the low base bid.

| Bidder   | Base bid, % of the low base bid | Rank on base bid |
| -------- | ------------------------------- | ---------------- |
| Bidder A | 100%                            | 1                |
| Bidder B | 109%                            | 2                |
| Bidder C | 163%                            | 3                |
| Bidder D | 163%                            | 4                |

Two bids sat close together and two sat far above them. Bidders C and D both came in at 163% of the low.

## What did each plumbing bid leave out or leave unclear?

Every bidder left out at least one scope line. No bidder left a line unclear. The table counts the lines.

| Bidder   | Lines excluded | Lines unclear |
| -------- | -------------- | ------------- |
| Bidder A | 3              | 0             |
| Bidder B | 2              | 0             |
| Bidder C | 1              | 0             |
| Bidder D | 2              | 0             |

Bidder A had the low base bid and the most excluded lines. That is why a low number needs a second look. Bidder C had the fewest exclusions, and its price was still 63% above the low.

The case records no exclusion categories for these bidders. This page does not say which kinds of work the excluded lines were.

Across Consight's published benchmark, 55% of leveled plumbing bids exclude at least one scope line (199 bids, 67 packages, 65 projects, 25 organizations). One organization supplies 32% of those bids. Without it, the share is 57%.

## What did the plugs add to the plumbing bids?

A plug is the estimator's price for scope a bidder missed, excluded, or underpriced. The case records every bidder's plugs as 0% of the low base bid.

In Consight, the [leveled price](https://consight.ai/reference/pricing-and-leveling#base-bid-vs-leveled-price-explained) includes plugs, corrected quantities, and scope the estimator added to make bids comparable. The case records the plugs, but not the other adjustments.

The case records 5 reviewed calls and 5 estimator corrections. It does not say what the calls were or what the corrections changed, so this page does not guess.

## Did the low plumbing bid stay lowest after leveling?

Yes. The ranks held, and every leveled price matched its base bid.

| Bidder   | Rank on base bid | Leveled price, % of the low leveled price | Rank after leveling |
| -------- | ---------------- | ----------------------------------------- | ------------------- |
| Bidder A | 1                | 100%                                      | 1                   |
| Bidder B | 2                | 109%                                      | 2                   |
| Bidder C | 3                | 163%                                      | 3                   |
| Bidder D | 4                | 163%                                      | 4                   |

The spread from low to high was 63% before leveling and 63% after. Bidder A stayed the [low bid](https://consight.ai/articles/comparing-hvac-bids-case-study) at both steps.

Leveling confirmed the order here. It still does not decide the award. Compare qualifications, schedule, and bonding next. Our finishes case, [award when the low bid is not lowest](https://consight.ai/articles/award-when-the-low-bid-is-not-lowest), walks through that step. In an [electrical case](https://consight.ai/articles/comparing-electrical-bids-case-study), the low bid ranked second after leveling. A concrete case kept its low bid in first place, as this one did.

## What should an estimator check on every plumbing bid?

Run these checks bid by bid. For the full method on pipe trades, see [how to level mechanical and electrical bids](https://consight.ai/articles/how-to-level-mechanical-and-electrical-bids).

1. **Exclusions against your scope sheet.** Bidder A excluded 3 lines and Bidders B and D excluded 2 each. Match every excluded line to a plug or to another trade.
2. **Trenching and backfill.** Plumbing, electrical, and sitework can each carry it. Name one owner in writing.
3. **Trench protection.** OSHA's rule [1926.652](https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/29/1926.652) says each employee in an excavation "shall be protected from cave-ins by an adequate protective system." Ask who supplies shoring or sloping for the underground pipe.
4. **Underground utilities and exits.** OSHA's rule [1926.651](https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-29?part=1926&section=1926.651) covers the location of utility installations before digging. It also says "A stairway, ladder, ramp or other safe means of egress shall be located in trench excavations" that are 4 feet or deeper. Ask who locates utilities and who provides the egress.
5. **Prices far above the low.** Bidders C and D priced 63% above the low. Ask what their prices carry, and whether the gap is scope or margin.
6. **Reviewed calls.** The case holds 5 reviewed calls and 5 corrections. Review each bidder's Included, Excluded, and Needs review marks yourself before you trust a total.

For finding scope gaps, see [how to find scope gaps in subcontractor bids](https://consight.ai/articles/how-to-find-scope-gaps-in-subcontractor-bids).

## How does Consight show this?

[Level Bids](https://consight.ai/reference/autocomplete#run-level-bids) marks each scope line Included, Excluded, or Needs review for each bidder. You [add a plug](https://consight.ai/reference/pricing-and-leveling#add-a-plug-for-missing-or-unclear-scope) at your own price for each gap.

## How we measured

Every case figure comes from one recorded case, `22-plumbing-3f277dc4`, a Plumbing package leveled in Consight. The case holds no names, amounts, or dates. It rounds every percentage to a whole number. Base bids and plugs are percentages of the low base bid. Leveled prices are percentages of the low leveled price.

The case records the region as South and the size as 50,000 to 200,000 sq ft. It does not record the project type.

The 55% figure comes from Consight's published bid benchmark of 2026-11-09. It counts all leveled plumbing bids, and the AI detected the exclusions. The median gap between low and second-low plumbing bids is not published, because its sample is under the minimum. The OSHA quotes come from the regulation text at the linked pages.
