Before you award electrical, compare each bid on one scope sheet. Check who carries temporary power, pads, cutting and coring, permits, and engineering, then plug what each bid left out. In one five-bid electrical package, the low base bid ranked second after leveling, and the spread between bids grew from 15% to 79%.
Key takeaways
- Every base bid sat within 15% of the low.
- Each bidder left out or left unclear some scope. Bidder C had the most: 5 excluded lines and 1 unclear line.
- Bidder B had the fewest, 1 excluded line, and ranked first after leveling.
- Bidder A, the low base bid, ranked second. Its leveled price was 156% of the new low.
- The exclusions that split the field included temporary power, permits, bonds, and overtime.
What did the five electrical bids look like on bid day?
This case is one Electrical (Division 26) package on a commercial project in the South Census region. It had five bidders and a scope sheet of 23 lines. Consight read 7 files and 23 pages. The case records no names, amounts, or dates, so every price below is a percentage of the low.
Bidder A had the low base bid. Bidder E was highest, 15% above it. All five bids landed within 15% of the low, so the field looked tight and the choice looked easy.
| Bidder | Base bid, % of the low base bid | Rank on base bid |
|---|---|---|
| Bidder A | 100% | 1 |
| Bidder B | 104% | 2 |
| Bidder C | 108% | 3 |
| Bidder D | 109% | 4 |
| Bidder E | 115% | 5 |
Across Consight's published benchmark, the median gap between the low and second-low base bid on electrical packages is 15% (42 packages, 41 projects, 14 organizations, base bids before leveling).
What did each electrical bid leave out?
Each bid left out something. The table counts the scope lines each bidder excluded or left unclear.
| Bidder | Lines excluded | Lines unclear |
|---|---|---|
| Bidder A | 2 | 2 |
| Bidder B | 1 | 0 |
| Bidder C | 5 | 1 |
| Bidder D | 3 | 0 |
| Bidder E | 2 | 0 |
Each case holds per bidder its excluded and unclear items, so this table counts lines and the next tables name kinds of work.
Which exclusions did every bidder share?
Bidders A, B, C, D, and E each left out or left unclear these: cleanup, dumpsters, or disposal; patching or painting; engineering or design; and cutting, coring, or sleeves. Those items belong on your own scope sheet or in a plug for every bid.
Bidders A, B, D, and E also named concrete or equipment pads. Bidder C did not. Across Consight's published electrical data, 84% of captured exclusion lists name concrete or equipment pads (116 bids, 34 packages, 30 projects, 12 organizations).
Which exclusions split the field?
The rest of the exclusions fell on some bidders and not others.
| Kind of work | Bidders that left it out or unclear |
|---|---|
| Temporary power, water, or facilities | A, C |
| Permits or fees | A, C, D, E |
| Bonds | A, B, C, D |
| Overtime or after-hours work | A, B, D |
| Hazardous materials | A, B, C |
| Excavation, rock, or backfill | D, E |
| Demolition | C |
| Hoisting, cranes, or lifts | C |
| Fire stopping or fire rating | C |
| Testing or inspection | E |
Bidder B left out neither temporary power nor permits. Bidder A, the low base bid, left out both.
What did the plugs add?
A plug is the estimator's price for scope a bidder missed, excluded, or underpriced. The case records every bidder's plugs as 0% of the low base bid. In Consight, the leveled price is the base bid plus plugs, corrected quantities, and scope the estimator added. Read the leveled prices below as recorded.
How did the ranks change after leveling?
After leveling, Bidder B had the low price. Bidder A, the original low, ranked second at 156% of the new low. Bidders C, D, and E stayed third, fourth, and fifth.
| Bidder | Rank on base bid | Leveled price, % of the low leveled price | Rank after leveling |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bidder A | 1 | 156% | 2 |
| Bidder B | 2 | 100% | 1 |
| Bidder C | 3 | 168% | 3 |
| Bidder D | 4 | 170% | 4 |
| Bidder E | 5 | 179% | 5 |
The spread from low to high grew from 15% to 79%. The two tables use different bases. Base bids are a percentage of Bidder A's base bid. Leveled prices are a percentage of Bidder B's leveled price.
After leveling, Bidder A was 56% above Bidder B, Bidder C 68%, Bidder D 70%, and Bidder E 79%.
What should you check in electrical bids before you award?
Check the items below on every electrical bid. Run them bid by bid. For the general method, see our guide to leveling mechanical and electrical bids.
- Temporary power and lighting. Bidders A and C left out temporary power, water, or facilities. Across Consight's published data, 70% of captured electrical exclusion lists name them (116 bids, 34 packages, 30 projects, 12 organizations). Settle who supplies the service, the distribution, and the removal.
- Temporary power safety. OSHA's rule 1926.404 requires ground-fault circuit interrupters on 120-volt outlets that employees use and that are not part of the permanent wiring, or an assured equipment grounding conductor program. Its rule 1926.405 says "Temporary wiring shall be removed immediately upon completion of construction or the purpose for which the wiring was installed." Ask the bidder what its temporary power price covers.
- Utility company charges. Across the published data, 36% of captured electrical exclusion lists name utility company charges or connections (116 bids, 34 packages, 30 projects, 12 organizations). Decide who pays the utility and who schedules the connection.
- Fire alarm and equipment lead times. Ask each bidder what its price carries for fire alarm and when its switchgear would arrive. Our MEP leveling guide covers fire alarm and temporary power at the trade boundaries.
- Pads, cutting, and firestopping. Bidders A, B, D, and E named pads. Bidder C named fire stopping or fire rating. Bidders A, B, C, D, and E all named cutting, coring, or sleeves.
- Permits, engineering, and bonds. Bidders A, C, D, and E left out permits or fees. Bidders A, B, C, and D left out bonds. Bidders A, B, C, D, and E all named engineering or design.
Across Consight's published electrical data, 68% of leveled electrical bids exclude at least one scope line (350 bids, 103 packages, 92 projects, 29 organizations). For finding the gaps, see how to find scope gaps in subcontractor bids.
What does leveling change about the award?
Compare leveled prices, then check each bidder's qualifications, schedule, safety record, and bonding. Our case study of a finishes package, award when the low bid is not lowest, walks through that second step.
How does Consight show this?
Consight reads each proposal and answers your Inclusions, Exclusions, Alternates, and Clarifications rows from each bid, as the help page describes. Level Bids also marks each scope line Included, Excluded, or Needs review for each bidder. You add a plug for each gap at your own price.
How we measured
Every case figure comes from one recorded case, 26-electrical-5d992238, an Electrical package leveled in Consight. The case holds no names, amounts, or dates. It rounds every percentage to a whole number. Base bids and plugs are percentages of the low base bid. Leveled prices are percentages of the low leveled price.
No estimator reviews are recorded for this case.
The shares of exclusion lists come from Consight's published bid benchmark. They count only bids with at least one exclusion captured, and the AI detected the exclusions. The 68% figure counts all leveled electrical bids. The 15% median gap is a recorded value over base bids as submitted.
Where Consight fits
Consight is the preconstruction workspace built around this kind of work—from understanding project documents and building scopes to collecting bids, leveling proposals, reviewing risk, and documenting the final award.
Put it into practice on your next project.
Talk to sales